Today I met with a Korean friend and a Japanese friend to be social and practice our language skills. Near the end of our time together the question was brought up by my Korean friend. Are shows like Cheaters and Jerry Springer representative of American Culture? I told her no of course and had to explain the reality of these shows is that they are on the edge shows that show an extreme side of American culture and that most Americans like most Koreans are hard working family oriented people who live lives not much different than Korean families. Who work long hours and enjoy time with their immediate family throughout the year and their extended families during major events throughout the year like Christmas, Easter, and Thanksgiving.


As Americans we have a choice of how we are represented to the world and what we can watch. If this is what is being exported then this may be one of the reasons we are viewed so poorly. Ah, the phrase ugly American rings loud through these shows. I believe it rings "look at what idiots we can be" and tells people that there is a whole country full of us. We need to speak up as Americans and let the networks know that this is not what we want to be portrayed as. I am saddened to think that this is what we are viewed as. People who can not keep to one relationship or who want to have their "dirty laundry" so to speak aired across the world. We need to find a way to show the normal side of family life to the rest of the world and the good nature of Americans as a whole.


Comments
on Jul 27, 2004
The problem is that as long as people keep watching these shows they will still get advertisers and stay on ther air. It really is all about money. I think the main thing you can do is not watch these shows or you could start writing letters to the companies that advertise on these shows and say that you will not purchase their products as long as they advertise on these "trash TV" shows.
on Jul 27, 2004
Ever seen Takeshi's Castle ?

Does life imitate art or art imitate life? I urge you to look deeper.
on Jul 27, 2004
Perhaps the problem is that television reflects American life more accurately than we wish to percieve it, and we don't make the cut morally or culturally.
on Jul 27, 2004
The world is full of idiots, don't worry. Americans are just a little less bashful about showing that than other folks. I think people realize these types of things happen world-wide - they just aren't televised.

JW

PS I think the quality of TV is terrible in general, but wadda gunna do 'bout it? A hopeless case, I think, except by voting with your feet - so to speak.
on Jul 28, 2004
Ok. let's break this down a little. Reality shows may reflect a portion of our culture in America but not all of it likely not even half to one quarter. One can not lump reality TV shows all together anyways. From what I have seen and I am not a complete reality show junkie because I personally opt out of watching most of them there are at least four kinds of reality shows.

1.)There are the reality TV shows that everyone involved knows what's going on (Survivor, Bachelor, Bachelorette, The Apprentice, the next big model, temptation island, Fear Factor, American Idol, Takeshi's Castle, Big Brother, Real World, the great race, that CBS adoption episode, and the mole to name a few) ;

2.) the reality TV shows that one of the parties knows what's going on and is trying to confront the other party (Cheaters, Jerry Springer),

3.) there are the reality TV shows where participants are mislead into believing they know what they are getting involved in but the actual show is completely different ( Bachelor knock off where the women were told he was a millionaire and he wasn't some of the late night talk shows) and

3.) there is the documentary version tv shows (life in the ER, veterinary ER, baby stories and cops). These are just a few and there are plenty out there to fill any hole we might want to fill.

I don't have issues with the reality shows that people legitimately know what they are getting involved in. Granted I enjoy shows like the mole and survivor and even a little Takeshi's Castle from time to time but my point is I think that these shows are viewed differently than the unknown suspect shows. This
first category of shows are viewed as people legitimately challenging themselves as a mountain climber would challenge themselves to climbing or bowler trying to get that perfect 300 game OR as people trying to fulfill their dreams. I think people look at the majority of these shows as examples of the American dream in the sense that if you really work hard enough you can achieve your goals.
Granted there is a class of even this first kind of show where you just go " what are these people thinking? (i.e. Temptation Island)" I think that this is a poor choice to solve relationship issues but it's their choice not mine. As much as I think having someone choose a couple to adopt their baby on national TV is a bad choice for 60 minutes especially.

I don't have issues with the reality documentary shows either.

My issue is with the one or both unsuspecting party shows. These are the shows that make us look bad as Americans because they show us as being deceitful and untrustworthy and having loose morals. And why because that is exactly what these shows are based on and it is not the other two types of shows that are being exported to foreign lands it is these shows of deception.

As an American living outside of the US that challenge is put upon me to make sure that I am not lumped into this percentage of people. And I legitimately think that other American Expats do not want to be lumped into this group either. Anymore than someone who is black wants to be labeled a thug or someone who is middle eastern wants to be profiled as a terrorist. Come on. I urge you to look a little deeper.

Yes, I agree with Jay that as Americans we tend to air our dirty laundry a little more readily than the rest of the world but I think in part because a characteristic of American culture is " it happened oh well, pick yourself and move on." Americans still have some of the biggest hearts in the world when it comes to stepping up and helping each other out. But once again that is part of our culture and we should be proud of that. And some shows do show this part of our culture.

I realize the extreme portions of our society are what even we as Americans find entertaining. I am just saying it's sad that the deceitful low moral portion is what we have to show the world every night in syndicated television.

on Jul 29, 2004

A lot of the more "objectionable" programming that you're mentioning isn't exactly prime-time fare.

I don't know about Korea, but living in Japan for nearly five years  I have seen some pretty racy stuff on television that is at least as mindless as a Jerry Springer episode.

on Jul 29, 2004
I think the point here is in the title of these shows... 'reality' TV is far from reality. Yet if I spoke another language, and had never come across the concept (I guess it is a colloquialism) then I would be forced to interpret this type of show as portaying the 'reality' of Western (i.e. American) life.

As a westerner I don't really quite understand the attraction of reality TV. Whether it comes from some latent desire to see people hurt others without being hurt in turn, whether it is a fascination with doing things we would never dare to do ourselves, or a simple horror that these people would put themselves through such anguish for money or physical satisfaction. Whatever it is, it is VERY popular, and what is popular will always attract those who wish to exploit that popularity for big bucks... and so perpetuate the cycle.

Growing up I watched programs like the Cosby's and game shows and other more 'family' oriented programming. With the changing of the generations though the programming demands have also changed, and now if we are to believe the figures of who watches what, family TV no longer rakes in the bickies that TV execs need to show it.

i completely agree that it would be nice to go back to some good, clean, 'normal' programs... but unfortunately normality doesn't sell, sex, backstabbing, bitching, hardship and bloodshed does. I can't see programming changing in the next few years without some radical shifts in view from the general public. Good on you for bringing up the point C & H Wood, I heartily hope that something is done, and I will stick my hand up and support it when it happens, until then I'm crossing my fingers but not holding my breath.
on Jul 29, 2004
To be honest, what a lot of US shows say about the US is that US citizens like to watch stupid people mess up. That doesn't mean all US people are stupid, but they are the most visible ones, and it doesn't paint much of a rosy picture about the viewers either.
on Aug 06, 2004
Yeah, I would venture that Korean TV has equally mind-numbing-offensive-bordering-on-R-Rated-yet-delightfully-tacky stuff on TV at night as well.
on Aug 06, 2004
I enjoyed the Survivor shows but can't stand most of the "reality" shows.  I have never sat through an episode of Springer.  I seriously question the "reality" of that show.  I do, however enjoy shows like Cops.  At least with Cops people know it is a show about criminals and not Americans in general.  At least I hope they know that.
on Aug 06, 2004
I've heard Japanese TV can get kinda wild, but so far Korean TV seems very tame, even by American standards. I mean, they might be trash-talking each other on the 24-hour Go channel, but I don't get that impression. Most of the rest of the TV is news, learning English, home-shopping, US imports of some really bad stuff, soap operas, historical samurai style soap operas, video game channels, and lots more home-shopping. The only thing racy I've seen is the English dialoge. They show movies without any bleeps, so you get the R-rated dialoge at full face value. I'll have to write another blog on that one, though since sometimes it can be very funny.

Anyway, there might be more racy things going on, but I haven't seen it yet. Obviously we're not spending a ton of time inside watching TV, but haveing done a far amount of channel surfing, if it's out there on Korean TV, it's not common. Of course, that doesn't make the Korean programming pure, after all they import and show all of the American crap. They just seem to be content to out-source for that. Manipulative Exploitative TV: Finially an industry that is immune to off-shoring!

C